Buy Vs. Rent: Hot Water Tank Or Furnace
By Darren McClurg, Certified Master Inspector® ·


Buy vs. Rent: Hot Water Tank or Furnace Insights
Here is the late horrific news for some & perfect insight to others. Don’t always think a furnace or hot water tank company is your new best friend, they won’t be coming to this weekends BBQ. They just want your money & they’ll just go to the next person after you.
So skip the starbucks or timmies for a month, don’t worry they’ll be an emotional wreck because they lost you for only .00000001 microsecond. Save yourself they headache & financial stress, read below & this will help you make the proper decision.
HOT WATER TANK-
A brand new hot water tank typically comes with a warranty, often ranging from 6 to 12 years
Cost 50 gal. electric water tank $529- $3,682
Ottawa typically range from $16 to $60 per month or higher.
While monthly rental fees may appear lower initially, they can accumulate over years 2-4% & include hidden fees, installation costs, and potentially higher maintenance costs.
Some rental agreements, like those offered by other providers, require a minimum term of 72-84 months, according to Hot Water Ottawa.
Here’s the equation: $60×12 months= $720x 15years= $10,800+ taxes (So you could have purchased 2-20 depending on the size & given a 5-10year warranty witch each)
FURNACE –
A brand new furnace typically comes with a manufacturer’s warranty, usually covering parts for 5-10 years, and a 20-year limited warranty on the heat exchanger. Some manufacturers also offer limited coverage for labor during the first year of installation.
Cost for 42,000 btu furnace $1,986- $3,945
Ottawa typically falls within a monthly rental range of $52 to $129.99/month plus tax
While monthly rental fees may appear lower initially, they can accumulate over years 2-4% & include hidden fees, installation costs, and potentially higher maintenance costs.
Contracts typically range from 7 to 15 years, which affects the overall cost of the rental program.
cheapest: Here’s the equation: $52×12 months= $624x 15years= $9,360+ taxes (So with the cheapest rental, you could have purchased 3-5 depending on the size & given a 5-10year warranty with each)
Expensive: Here’s the equation: $129×12 months= $1,548x 15years= $23,220+ taxes (So with the expensive rental, you could have purchased 6-11 depending on the size & given a 5-10year warranty with each)

Trapped in a Rental Agreement: Why Renting Your Furnace and Hot Water Tank Can Be a Costly Mistake
That flyer slipped under your door, promising worry-free comfort for a low monthly fee. Sounds appealing, right? Especially when faced with the hefty upfront cost of a new furnace or hot water tank. But before you sign on the dotted line to rent these essential home appliances, let’s pull back the curtain and expose why this seemingly convenient option can often turn into a long-term financial burden.
The Illusion of Affordability:
The biggest lure of renting is the low monthly payment. It feels much easier on the wallet than shelling out thousands of dollars upfront. However, over the lifespan of the rental agreement – often stretching for 15 years – these seemingly small payments add up. And they add up… a lot. You’ll likely end up paying far more for the equipment than it would have cost to purchase it outright, sometimes even several times the original value!
Locked In and Losing Flexibility:
Rental agreements are contracts, and breaking them often comes with significant penalties. What happens if you want to sell your house? The new buyers might not want to inherit your rental agreement, leaving you on the hook for hefty termination fees. Suddenly, that “worry-free” rental becomes a major obstacle in a significant life event. Owning your equipment gives you the freedom to choose what happens to it when you move.
Paying for Repairs Anyway (Sometimes!):
One of the selling points of renting is often the inclusion of maintenance and repairs. However, read the fine print carefully. Some agreements have limitations on what’s covered, and you might still find yourself paying for certain repairs or facing delays in service. When you own your equipment, you have the power to choose your own trusted technician and aren’t tied to the rental company’s service schedule.

No Equity, No Return:
Think of it this way: with each rental payment, you’re essentially throwing money away. You’re building no equity in the appliance. At the end of your rental term, you own nothing. When you purchase your furnace or hot water tank, it’s an investment in your home. It adds to the value of your property and eventually, you own it outright.
The “Convenience” Tax:
Ultimately, renting often boils down to paying a premium for convenience. While the initial low cost might seem attractive, the long-term financial implications can be significant. You’re essentially paying interest on an appliance you’ll never truly own.
Consider the Alternatives:
Before opting for a rental, explore other options:
- Saving Up: While it requires patience, saving for a new furnace or hot water tank is the most financially sound approach in the long run.
- Financing: Many retailers offer financing options that can make the upfront cost more manageable, allowing you to own the equipment.
- Government Rebates and Incentives: Look into available grants and rebates that can help offset the cost of purchasing energy-efficient models.
The Bottom Line:
Renting your furnace and hot water tank might seem like a quick and easy solution, but it often leads to a long-term financial drain and a lack of control. By understanding the true costs and exploring alternative options, you can make a more informed decision that benefits your wallet in the long run. Don’t get trapped in a rental agreement – take control of your home comfort and consider ownership instead.